Ginger Root For Bloating Supplement Review

Ginger Root For Bloating Supplement Review

Quick Summary: Ginger root has genuine clinical backing for digestive relief, but not all supplements are created equal. This review breaks down the science, the best forms, the right dosage, and which products are worth your money — so you can stop guessing and start feeling better.


Table of Contents

  1. What Is Ginger Root and Why Do People Use It for Bloating?
  2. How Does Ginger Root Help With Bloating? The Science Explained
  3. Ginger Root Supplement Forms: Capsules, Tea, Extract, and More
  4. Ginger Root Dosage for Bloating: What the Research Says
  5. Top Ginger Root Supplements for Bloating: Our Honest Review
  6. Ginger Root vs. Ginger + Artichoke Combinations
  7. Side Effects and Who Should Avoid Ginger Supplements
  8. Frequently Asked Questions
  9. Final Verdict: Is a Ginger Root Bloating Supplement Worth It?

What Is Ginger Root and Why Do People Use It for Bloating?

If you've ever clutched your stomach after a heavy meal, scrolled through a sea of remedies, and landed on ginger root — you're in good company. For thousands of years, cultures from India to China to ancient Greece have turned to ginger as a go-to digestive aid. Today, it's one of the most searched natural remedies for gut discomfort, and the supplement market has responded with dozens of capsules, extracts, and teas all promising fast, effective relief.

But does ginger root bloating relief actually hold up under scientific scrutiny, or is this just ancient folklore dressed up in a modern bottle?

The short answer is: there's real evidence here, though it comes with important nuances. This review is designed for buyers — people who are actively considering purchasing a ginger root supplement and want honest, research-backed guidance before spending their money.

Ginger (Zingiber officinale) is a flowering plant whose underground rhizome — the part we call the "root" — contains a dense array of bioactive compounds. The most studied of these are gingerols (abundant in fresh ginger) and shogaols (more concentrated in dried ginger and extracts). Both compounds interact with the digestive system in ways that researchers are still working to fully understand, but the evidence so far is encouraging for people dealing with bloating, gas, and general digestive discomfort.

Support Your Gut System, Reduce Bloating and Feel Lighter Within Minutes.

Try our new organic debloat + digest drops risk free

Shop Organic Debloat + Digest Drops

The surge in popularity of natural ginger root bloating remedies is no accident. Millions of people deal with functional digestive complaints — bloating, gas, slow digestion, and feelings of fullness that linger long after eating — without a formal diagnosis. Prescription options are limited, often carry side effects, and don't always address the root cause. Ginger root offers a gentler, more accessible alternative, and when you understand exactly how it works, why it works for some people more than others, and how to choose the right product and dose, it becomes a genuinely useful tool in your digestive health toolkit.


How Does Ginger Root Help With Bloating? The Science Explained

To understand why ginger root and bloating relief are so closely linked in the research, you need to understand what actually causes bloating in the first place.

Bloating isn't just one problem — it's typically the result of several overlapping issues:

  • Excess gas production from fermentation of undigested food in the colon
  • Slow gastric emptying (food sitting in the stomach too long)
  • Reduced gastrointestinal motility (sluggish movement of contents through the digestive tract)
  • Constipation, which traps gas and creates pressure
  • Visceral hypersensitivity, where the gut feels discomfort more intensely than normal

Ginger root appears to address several of these mechanisms simultaneously, which is one reason it stands out among natural digestive remedies.

Improving Gastrointestinal Motility

According to Johns Hopkins Medicine, one of ginger's primary mechanisms for helping with bloating and gas is its ability to improve gastrointestinal motility — essentially, how efficiently your digestive system moves food through the gut. When motility is impaired, food ferments longer in the colon, producing more gas and contributing directly to bloating. Ginger's bioactive compounds appear to stimulate the enteric nervous system (the "second brain" in your gut), encouraging more coordinated muscular contractions that move food along faster.

Reducing Fermentation and Constipation

Johns Hopkins also notes that ginger may help reduce fermentation and constipation — both major contributors to bloating with ginger root addressing the problem at the source rather than just masking symptoms. By keeping the digestive tract moving and reducing the time food has to sit and ferment, ginger can decrease overall gas production rather than simply treating the gas after it forms.

Stimulating Digestive Enzymes and Juices

A 2024 review summarized by Healthline found that ginger may support digestive health — particularly in conditions like IBS and IBD — by promoting gastric motility and stimulating digestive juices. When your body produces sufficient digestive enzymes and stomach acid, food is broken down more efficiently, leaving less undigested material to reach the colon and ferment into gas.

Anti-Inflammatory Effects on the Gut

The same 2024 review suggested that approximately 2,000 mg per day of ginger may help reduce inflammation and dyspepsia (general stomach upset), and may even offer protective effects against colorectal issues and ulceration in the digestive tract. This anti-inflammatory action is relevant to bloating because gut inflammation — even low-grade, subclinical inflammation — can impair motility, increase visceral sensitivity, and worsen bloating symptoms.

The Evidence Quality: An Honest Assessment

Before we go further, it's worth being upfront about something important. A 2020 systematic review of ginger clinical trials found that only 43 out of 109 clinical trials (39.4%) met the authors' criteria for high quality of evidence. The review also noted that many studies had small sample sizes and unstandardized evaluation systems. This doesn't mean ginger doesn't work — it means the research, while promising, still has room to grow. The mechanistic evidence is solid, and multiple human trials do show real benefits, but you should approach any supplement claim with calibrated expectations.

The ginger root benefits bloating picture is genuine, but ginger is a complement to good digestive health practices — not a magic pill.


Ginger Root Supplement Forms: Capsules, Tea, Extract, and More

One of the most common questions buyers have is: does it matter how you take ginger? The answer is yes — the form significantly affects how much active compound you're getting and how quickly it acts.

Ginger Root Capsules

Capsules are the most studied and most standardized form for therapeutic use. When manufacturers specify a concentration of gingerols or shogaols on the label, you can reliably compare products and doses. Capsules are also convenient, taste-neutral (important if you don't enjoy ginger's spicy bite), and easy to take with or before meals. For people looking for the most consistent ginger root bloating supplement experience, capsules are typically the top recommendation.

Look for capsules that specify:

  • Total ginger root amount (in mg)
  • Whether it's a whole root powder or standardized extract
  • The percentage of active gingerols/shogaols if using an extract

Ginger Root Extract

Ginger root extract bloating products are more concentrated than standard capsule powders. An extract is typically standardized to a specific percentage of active compounds — for example, 5% gingerols — meaning you can take a smaller dose (often 100–300 mg) and still receive a therapeutically relevant amount of active ingredient. This makes extracts efficient and potent, but also means you need to be more careful about dosing.

ConsumerLab's independent testing of ginger supplements (one of the top resources for supplement verification) has found significant variation in the actual gingerol content of products on the market — some containing far less than labeled, others far more. This makes third-party testing certifications (NSF, USP, ConsumerLab Approved) especially important when choosing a ginger extract product.

Ginger Root Tea

Ginger root tea bloating is perhaps the most traditional form and remains genuinely useful, particularly for mild or acute digestive discomfort. A cup of freshly brewed ginger tea after a large meal or when you first notice bloating can provide relatively quick, gentle relief. However, the amount of active gingerols in a cup of tea is significantly lower and less consistent than a standardized capsule or extract. Variables like steep time, water temperature, whether you're using fresh ginger versus a bagged tea, and the quality of the product all affect potency.

Is ginger tea as effective as ginger capsules for bloating? For mild, occasional bloating, tea can absolutely help and has the added benefit of hydration. For moderate to significant bloating, or for people looking for consistent daily use, standardized capsules or extracts provide more reliable dosing.

Fresh Ginger Root

Consuming fresh ginger — grated into food, blended into smoothies, or steeped into tea — is excellent for general digestive wellness and cooking, but the dose is unpredictable. The gingerol content in fresh ginger varies by source, age, and storage conditions. For supplemental use with a therapeutic goal, fresh ginger works best as a complement rather than a primary strategy.

Ginger Chewables and Combination Products

Some of the most interesting recent research involves chewable supplements that combine ginger with artichoke extract — we'll cover that in detail in a later section. These products offer the potential added benefit of multiple mechanisms working together and may be preferable for people who struggle to swallow capsules.

Support Your Gut System, Reduce Bloating and Feel Lighter Within Minutes.

Try our new organic debloat + digest drops risk free

Shop Organic Debloat + Digest Drops

Ginger Root Dosage for Bloating: What the Research Says

Getting the ginger root dosage bloating piece right is one of the most important — and most frequently misunderstood — parts of using ginger supplements effectively.

What Doses Have Been Used in Research?

Clinical trials on ginger for digestive complaints have used a fairly wide range of doses, which reflects both the variety of conditions studied and the lack of standardization the 2020 systematic review highlighted. Here's what the evidence suggests across different use cases:

| Use Case | Studied Dose Range | Notes | |---|---|---| | General digestive support / bloating | 500 mg – 1,500 mg/day | Whole root powder, divided doses | | Gastric emptying / motility | 1,000 mg – 1,500 mg before meals | Often studied in single doses | | Anti-inflammatory / dyspepsia | Up to 2,000 mg/day | Per the 2024 Healthline-summarized review | | Nausea (motion sickness, pregnancy) | 250 mg – 1,000 mg | Most extensively studied dose range |

The 2024 review data suggesting 2,000 mg/day may help with inflammation and dyspepsia is notable, but it's also at the higher end of the range and comes with a reminder to pay attention to potential side effects (discussed below). Most bloating-specific use cases in clinical trials cluster in the 500 mg to 1,500 mg per day range, which is also where most reputable supplement manufacturers pitch their products.

When Should You Take Ginger for Bloating?

Timing matters. For bloating with ginger root supplementation:

  • Before meals — Some trial protocols, particularly those studying gastric emptying, used ginger before eating to prime the digestive system. The Prodigest® studies Dr. Ruscio references used pre-meal dosing to speed gastric emptying versus placebo.
  • With meals — For general digestive support and reducing post-meal bloating, taking ginger with or immediately after eating is also commonly used.
  • At the first sign of bloating — For acute use, ginger tea or a chewable taken when symptoms begin can help.

How Fast Does a Ginger Supplement Work for Bloating?

This is one of the most common questions people ask. In acute situations (taking a dose when bloating has already started), many people notice some relief within 30 to 60 minutes, particularly with ginger tea or chewable forms. For capsules, onset may be slightly slower due to digestion time. For longer-term, prevention-focused use — taking ginger daily to reduce the frequency and severity of bloating — consistent use over 2 to 4 weeks tends to show the most meaningful results in clinical trials.

Whole Root Powder vs. Standardized Extract: Dosing Differences

This is where buyers often get confused. A product labeled "500 mg Ginger Root" could mean:

  • 500 mg of ground, dried whole root powder — Contains a relatively low percentage of gingerols (typically 0.5–1%)
  • 500 mg of standardized ginger extract (5% gingerols) — Contains approximately 25 mg of actual gingerols — potentially 5–10x the active compound of an equivalent dose of powder

Neither is inherently better, but the extract is more potent per milligram. When you see ginger root extract bloating products with lower mg counts (say, 100–250 mg), it's often because the higher standardization means less total material is needed. Always read the label carefully.


Top Ginger Root Supplements for Bloating: Our Honest Review

With hundreds of products on the market, we've evaluated the options based on the following criteria:

  • Transparency of labeling (standardized extract vs. whole root powder clearly indicated)
  • Third-party testing (NSF, USP, ConsumerLab verification)
  • Dose appropriateness (based on the clinical literature reviewed above)
  • Form and convenience
  • Value for money
  • User feedback patterns (common themes in verified reviews)

Support Your Gut System, Reduce Bloating and Feel Lighter Within Minutes.

Try our new organic debloat + digest drops risk free

Shop Organic Debloat + Digest Drops

What to Look for on the Label

Before diving into individual products, here are the non-negotiables when shopping for the best ginger root for bloating:

✅ Green flags:

  • Standardized extract with gingerol percentage listed
  • Third-party testing certification
  • Clear serving size and total daily dose
  • GMP (Good Manufacturing Practice) certified facility
  • No unnecessary fillers, artificial colors, or allergens

🚩 Red flags:

  • "Proprietary blend" that hides individual ingredient amounts
  • No mention of gingerol content
  • Implausibly high claimed doses (e.g., "10,000 mg per serving")
  • No third-party testing
  • Vague claims like "maximum strength" without supporting data

Product Category Breakdown

Best Standardized Extract (Capsule): Look for products offering 250–500 mg of ginger extract standardized to at least 5% gingerols. These give you the most consistent, research-aligned dose. Brands that have passed ConsumerLab testing are a safe starting point — ConsumerLab's ginger supplement review is one of the most rigorous independent analyses available and regularly updates its findings.

Best Whole Root Powder Capsule: For people who prefer a more whole-food approach, a high-quality 550–1,000 mg whole root powder capsule (taken 2–3 times daily with meals) is appropriate. Choose organic-certified options from brands with strong manufacturing transparency.

Best Ginger + Artichoke Combination: Based on the clinical research we'll cover in the next section, combination products featuring both ginger and artichoke extract — particularly those using the Prodigest® formulation or similar ratios — deserve serious consideration for people whose bloating is related to slow gastric emptying.

Best Ginger Tea for Bloating: For occasional use or as a complement to capsules, look for teas made with real ginger root (not just ginger flavoring). Loose-leaf teas steeped from actual dried ginger slices provide the most active compound delivery of any tea form.


Ginger Root vs. Ginger + Artichoke Combinations

One of the most compelling areas of recent ginger research — and one that directly answers a common buyer question — involves whether ginger works better alone or in combination with other ingredients.

The short answer: for certain types of bloating, particularly those linked to slow gastric emptying and functional dyspepsia, the combination of ginger and artichoke extract appears to outperform ginger alone.

The Prodigest® Research

Dr. Michael Ruscio, a clinician specializing in gut health, highlights two specific randomized controlled trials involving ginger + artichoke formulations:

Trial 1: A randomized controlled trial in athletes where a ginger + artichoke extract chewable helped relieve bloat, flatulence, and diarrhea. The athlete population is interesting here because intense exercise is known to cause significant digestive stress, making this a meaningful test population.

Trial 2: A randomized controlled trial showing that Prodigest® — a specific ginger + artichoke supplement taken before a meal — helped speed gastric emptying versus placebo. Gastric emptying speed is directly relevant to bloating: when the stomach empties more slowly, food ferments longer, more gas accumulates, and the uncomfortable feeling of fullness and distension persists.

Why Artichoke Complements Ginger

Artichoke leaf extract (Cynara scolymus) works via slightly different mechanisms than ginger. It primarily stimulates bile production and flow (choleretic action) and has been shown to have its own prokinetic effects — meaning it also helps move food through the digestive tract. When combined with ginger's motility-enhancing and anti-fermentation properties, the two ingredients appear to create a more comprehensive approach to digestive support than either alone.

If your primary bloating triggers are:

  • Heavy, fatty meals → Ginger + artichoke combo (bile support from artichoke is particularly useful)
  • Large meal volume / feeling of fullness → Ginger + artichoke combo (gastric emptying benefit)
  • Post-carbohydrate bloating / gas → Ginger alone or ginger + artichoke
  • General daily bloating / IBS-type symptoms → Standardized ginger extract, taken consistently

2024 Update on Ginger for IBS and IBD

A 2024 review highlighted by Healthline found that ginger may offer specific support for people with IBS (Irritable Bowel Syndrome) and IBD (Inflammatory Bowel Disease) by promoting gastric motility, stimulating digestive juices, and relieving GI discomfort. This is significant for the large proportion of chronic bloating sufferers whose symptoms overlap with functional gut disorders. While ginger is not a treatment for IBS or IBD, it may reduce symptom burden in these populations — and for buyers with these conditions, that's meaningful information.

Support Your Gut System, Reduce Bloating and Feel Lighter Within Minutes.

Try our new organic debloat + digest drops risk free

Shop Organic Debloat + Digest Drops

Side Effects and Who Should Avoid Ginger Supplements

Every honest supplement review needs a frank discussion of safety. Natural ginger root bloating remedies are generally very well tolerated, but that doesn't mean risk-free — especially at supplemental doses.

Common, Mild Side Effects

At typical supplemental doses (500–1,500 mg/day), the most commonly reported side effects are:

  • Heartburn or reflux — Somewhat ironic given ginger's reputation as a digestive aid, but higher doses can relax the lower esophageal sphincter in some individuals, worsening acid reflux
  • Mild stomach upset or nausea — Usually occurs when taking ginger on an empty stomach
  • Mouth or throat irritation — More common with raw ginger or high-dose extracts
  • Diarrhea — At higher doses in sensitive individuals

These effects are typically dose-dependent and resolve when the dose is reduced or the supplement is taken with food.

Higher-Dose Risks: What Johns Hopkins Says

Johns Hopkins Medicine specifically flags that ginger supplements may carry higher-dose risks, including:

  • Potential bleeding risk — Ginger has mild antiplatelet (blood-thinning) properties. At supplemental doses, this effect is generally minor, but it becomes significant if you're taking blood-thinning medications (like warfarin, aspirin in therapeutic doses, or newer anticoagulants like rivaroxaban) or if you have a clotting disorder.
  • Potential blood sugar effects — Ginger may have a mild blood glucose-lowering effect. For most people, this is inconsequential or even beneficial. However, people taking diabetes medications (particularly insulin or sulfonylureas) should be cautious, as combining blood-sugar-lowering effects could cause hypoglycemia.

Who Should Avoid or Use Caution With Ginger Supplements

Speak to your doctor before taking ginger supplements if you:

  • Are taking blood-thinning medications (warfarin, clopidogrel, aspirin therapy)
  • Have a bleeding disorder
  • Are taking diabetes medications
  • Are pregnant (ginger at culinary amounts is generally considered safe in pregnancy, but high-dose supplements are a different matter — always consult your OB)
  • Are scheduled for surgery within two weeks (antiplatelet effects)
  • Have gallstones (ginger stimulates bile flow, which could aggravate symptoms)
  • Are taking any medications metabolized by the liver's CYP enzyme system — theoretical interactions exist, though clinical significance is often low

Is Ginger Tea Safer Than Ginger Capsules?

Generally, yes — ginger root tea bloating remedies deliver lower doses of active compounds than capsules and extract, making side effects less likely. However, drinking large quantities of very strong ginger tea could produce similar effects to moderate supplement doses. Moderation applies to all forms.

A Note on Long-Term Use

Most safety studies on ginger have been relatively short-term (weeks to a few months). There's no strong evidence of harm from longer-term use at typical doses, but it's worth periodic reassessment — especially if you're using ginger to manage ongoing symptoms, which may warrant investigation into underlying causes.


Frequently Asked Questions

Does ginger root actually help with bloating?

Yes, with the caveat that the evidence quality varies. The mechanistic rationale is solid — ginger improves GI motility, reduces fermentation, stimulates digestive enzymes, and has anti-inflammatory effects. Multiple clinical trials have shown real benefits, and institutions like Johns Hopkins Medicine support its use for bloating and gas. The 2020 systematic review found that only about 39% of ginger trials met high-quality evidence criteria, so the research base is real but still developing. For most people with functional bloating (not caused by a specific medical condition), ginger root is a reasonable, well-supported first-line natural option.

How fast does a ginger supplement work for bloating?

For acute relief after a meal, ginger tea or a chewable supplement may provide noticeable relief within 30–60 minutes. For capsules, expect a slightly longer onset of 45–90 minutes as the capsule digests. For preventive daily use (reducing overall bloating frequency and severity), clinical trials typically see meaningful results after 2–4 weeks of consistent supplementation.

What is the best ginger dosage for bloating?

Most clinical research on bloating and digestive comfort clusters around 500 mg to 1,500 mg per day of ginger root (as whole root powder), typically divided into 2–3 doses taken with meals. The 2024 review data suggests up to 2,000 mg/day may be beneficial for inflammation and dyspepsia, but this higher end carries a greater risk of side effects. If using a standardized extract, effective doses are considerably lower — often 100–300 mg per day for extracts standardized to 5% gingerols or higher.

Is ginger tea as effective as ginger capsules for bloating?

For mild, occasional bloating, ginger tea absolutely works and has the additional benefit of being hydrating and warming. However, the dose of active gingerols in a cup of tea is significantly lower and less predictable than a standardized capsule. For moderate to significant bloating, or for consistent daily use with a therapeutic goal, standardized capsules provide more reliable results. Many people find using both — tea for acute relief and capsules for daily maintenance — to be the most effective combination.

Are there side effects from ginger supplements?

At typical doses, ginger supplements are well tolerated. The most common side effects are heartburn, mild nausea (especially on an empty stomach), and occasional diarrhea at higher doses. At higher supplemental doses, Johns Hopkins flags potential bleeding risk (particularly relevant for those on blood thinners) and possible blood sugar effects (relevant for people on diabetes medications). Always consult a healthcare provider if you take prescription medications before adding ginger supplements.

Can ginger help with gas and indigestion too?

Yes. Ginger's mechanisms — improving GI motility, reducing fermentation, stimulating bile and digestive enzyme production, and reducing inflammation — address not just bloating but also gas, indigestion (dyspepsia), and general feelings of digestive discomfort. The ginger root benefits bloating picture extends naturally to related GI complaints. In fact, some of the strongest clinical evidence for ginger involves functional dyspepsia rather than bloating specifically.

Is ginger better alone or combined with artichoke for bloating?

For general, mild-to-moderate bloating, ginger alone is a well-supported option. However, for bloating specifically related to slow gastric emptying, heavy meals, or functional dyspepsia, the combination of ginger + artichoke extract has stronger clinical backing. Two randomized controlled trials highlighted by Dr. Michael Ruscio showed ginger + artichoke formulations (including Prodigest®) significantly improving gastric emptying and relieving bloat, flatulence, and diarrhea compared to placebo. If your bloating is worst after large or fatty meals, a combination product is worth considering.

Who should avoid ginger supplements?

People who should be cautious or avoid ginger supplements without medical guidance include: those taking anticoagulant or antiplatelet medications, people with bleeding disorders, those taking diabetes medications, individuals scheduled for surgery within two weeks, pregnant women (at supplemental doses), and people with gallstones. Anyone with a chronic health condition or taking prescription medications should consult their healthcare provider before starting any new supplement.


Final Verdict: Is a Ginger Root Bloating Supplement Worth It?

After reviewing the clinical evidence, the available supplement forms, the dosing data, and the safety considerations, here's our honest verdict:

Yes — a well-chosen ginger root supplement is worth trying for most people dealing with bloating, gas, or functional digestive discomfort.

The evidence, while not uniformly high quality (the 2020 systematic review's finding that only ~39% of trials met high-quality criteria is worth remembering), is grounded in solid mechanistic science and supported by multiple positive human trials. Johns Hopkins Medicine endorses ginger for bloating and gas. A 2024 review supports its role in IBS, IBD, dyspepsia, and gastric motility. Randomized controlled trials support ginger (especially combined with artichoke) for gastric emptying and symptom relief.

Our Recommendations by Profile

For mild, occasional bloating: → Ginger root tea (high-quality, real ginger) or a 500 mg whole root capsule before/with meals. Low-cost, low-risk, easy to incorporate.

For moderate, regular bloating: → Standardized ginger root extract capsule (5% gingerols, 250–500 mg/day), taken consistently for at least 3–4 weeks. Look for third-party tested products.

For bloating after heavy or fatty meals / suspected slow gastric emptying: → Ginger + artichoke combination supplement, taken before meals. The clinical trial data here is compelling and specifically addresses gastric emptying.

For bloating with IBS or IBD: → Standardized ginger extract as part of a broader gut health strategy. The 2024 evidence for motility support and GI discomfort relief in these populations is encouraging, but work with a healthcare provider on a comprehensive approach.

The Bottom Line

Natural ginger root bloating relief isn't hype — it's a centuries-old remedy now backed by a growing (if imperfect) body of clinical science. The key is choosing the right product (standardized, third-party tested), the right dose (500–1,500 mg/day whole root, or lower for concentrated extracts), and the right form for your needs (capsules for consistency, tea for acute relief, combination products for gastric motility).

As with any supplement, set realistic expectations: ginger works best as part of a digestive health strategy that also addresses dietary triggers, stress, hydration, and gut microbiome health. But as standalone supplements go, the best ginger root for bloating products offer genuine value — and this review gives you everything you need to choose wisely.


Disclaimer: This review is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider before starting any new supplement, particularly if you have a medical condition or take prescription medications.


Sources Referenced:

  • ConsumerLab Ginger Supplement Review — consumerlab.com
  • Dr. Michael Ruscio, "Best Supplements for Bloating" — drruscio.com (2024)
  • Johns Hopkins Medicine, "Ginger Benefits" — hopkinsmedicine.org
  • 2020 Systematic Review of Ginger Clinical Trials
  • Healthline summary of 2024 Ginger + Digestive Health Review

0 comments

Leave a comment